"What is written without effort is in general read without pleasure." Samuel Johnson
Read with Pleasure - Johnson & Boswell - Two Partner Works: As time went on, it became more and more difficult to assign a meaningful research paper for the students to complete. The pressure towards the elimination of homework from parents, administration - and finally other teachers, made it in the end, impossible. There are two partner works here for students to do in class - after they have read the text book excerpt on Johnson and Boswell. The older one is designed to compliment the research paper. It has students look at their reading and take notes on it - as though they were writing a Background Research Paper on it. The more recent handout (lesson) does not require that a research paper is being done concurrently. This one gives students quotes about Johnson - written by the textbook writers - and asks them to find a supporting quote from Boswell's biography of Johnson (also found in the textbook) to support what the text book editors say. There is also a chance for students to create the ever-popular Samuel Johnson meme (see the banner above). Both exercises are worthwhile I believe and there is no reason that you couldn't do both.
As usual, there is a quiz here. Because it precedes a partner work you will want to grade the quiz - right away, before students get too far into the lesson. However - given the nature of both of these possible lessons - I did let students work on this during class, even if they didn't do the reading, with the following catch: I put students who did not do the reading together (these are partner works). There is an incredible fairness in that choice - not having done the reading will slow them substantially down - and it wouldn't be fair to partner with someone who DID do the reading.
NOTE: It is also possible to do these two in-class assignments without having done the reading. In some ways, that replicates doing research in the field. However, keep in mind that it will make things go much slower - but it will also add another layer of skill sets to the activity.
This is the more recent of the two activities. After an initial questions that gets the students to recall all the way back to September, and the research methods of The Venerable Bede - the students are asked to find a quote from Johnson's famous biographer: Bowell - that supports a fact about Johnson's life that was written by the text book's authors.
After that activity - if they have time (they should - this assignment is designed to be completed in one class period) the students are given two blank Samuel Johnson Memes, that they can contemplate and fill out to their hearts' delight.
This handout (and exercise) asks the students to imagine that they are working on a research paper. A "Background Study Paper" - the kind of research paper that I would never allow the students to actually do because it lacks a strong controversial thesis. It is essentially a "history" of a given subject or person. I give the students a topic: "Samuel Johnson's Dictionary"
It has the students
1. Go through the text looking for areas that they would want to take notes on. They are asked to use all of the formatting and conventions that we have been studying for the research paper.
2. For each note "area" (this is on the second page of the handout) they are asked to find a direct quote - again taking down all of the pertinent MLA information.
3. Now, the students are asked to imagine they've narrowed their topic to "The Writing of Samuel Johnson's Dictionary" and they are asked to look at a certain page of their text book that includes Johnson's letter to Lord Chesterfield - and they are asked to come up with a thesis - based on that reading. A kind of reverse-engineered thesis.
4. They repeat questions 1 & 2, using their newly found thesis.
5. They then are asked to write ONE paragraph based on the quotes and text - using their thesis to guide them.
6. Time permitting, they are to write a Works Cited List for their imagined Background Study Paper.
This is the more recent of the two activities. After an initial questions that gets the students to recall all the way back to September, and the research methods of The Venerable Bede - the students are asked to find a quote from Johnson's famous biographer: Bowell - that supports a fact about Johnson's life that was written by the text book's authors.
This handout (and exercise) asks the students to imagine that they are working on a research paper. A "Background Study Paper" - the kind of research paper that I would never allow the students to actually do because it lacks a strong controversial thesis. It is essentially a "history" of a given subject or person. I give the students a topic: "Samuel Johnson's Dictionary"
This quiz was for a fairly long reading, so though it is not marked on the quiz, I usually counted this for 150-200 points rather than the usual 100 points for a reading quiz. Remember - grade these immediately - and put students who did not read together (this is partner work), or they may work solo.
Students usually perform MUCH worse on historical/background quizzes than they do on fictional content quizzes. It may have something to do with fiction vs nonfiction retention and comprehension. This little exercise is designed to help them realize what they are doing wrong - and how they can make it better.
My reading was from the Holt Rinehart Winston textbook - Elements of Literature (course 6). Any textbook (or other sourced) readings on Samuel Johnson and Bowell will work - though you will have to modify the questions accordingly - especially as both of the assignments (and handouts) rely heavily on page numbers and very specific information.
Both of these can be done remotely of course - I've actually had great success with Partner Work remotely - it does take some planning though.
When we were forced to learn and teach remotely - due the Pandemic, it took me a long time to consider whether or not I should teach Defoe's "A Journal of the Plague Year". I had only taught it a few times in my 30 years of teaching - so there was no compulsion based on it being an invaluable part of the curriculum. However, this was different. We were in the middle of a deadly and life-changing Pandemic (much like Defoe's Plague - if perhaps not on the same scale) and it seemed that his words - had at this time - a lot to do with what we all were going through. On the other hand, it very well might have far too close - too triggering for those students (and myself) who had so recently lost family members to Covid-19. In the end - I knew that it was such a worthwhile endeavor. My first class of the year states that we read literature to "know that we're not alone".
Alexander Pope, "The Rape of the Lock" - Vertext Discussion or Group Work
I love how the pictures of Samuel Johnson reading a page of text - followed by a very puzzled look - became a popular meme. By allowing students to make their own memes using that construct - it also gave them a chance to poke some fun at their English Teacher.