Elizabethan 7 - Raleigh & Two Nymph Poems - If World & Love were  Young

"The flowers do fade, and wanton fields / To wayward winter reckoning yields."   "The Nymph's Reply"

Raleigh & Two Nymph Poems - If World & Love were young:   A VERY, VERY, VERY, VERY important lesson.   If the Wyatt and Howard poems are the first poems written in Modern English to be discussed - today we discuss poems - especially "The Nymph's Reply" that are Masterworks (in my opinion) of English (or any other) Poetry.  Sir Walter Raleigh is soooo good - and I believe his poem(s) will strike a chord with nearly every student in the class.  By this time of the year you will probably know your students well enough to understand if you should talk to some of them before the lesson - the lesson references ideas like love dying, divorce, and the end of things.  Because these are such big, and inevitable events (at least being touched by them)  in all of our lives - perhaps this is why these poems strike such powerful chord.

Lesson Overview 

If there is a quiz today - it is on Christopher Marlowe (the author of the first Nymph poem).  There is a separate reading in the students' textbook on Marlowe (a historical background and his nymph poem).  The students have already been quizzed on the Sir Walter Raleigh intro and poems (in the Raleigh & Elizabeth Lesson).  For the longest time, that first nymph poem, "The Passionate Shepherd to his Nymph" was the only Marlowe that we read in the class - which is a terrible shame - because it really is a horrible poem and the students get the wrong idea about Marlowe's talent.   To amend things, I did add a Marlowe poem that the students will go over when we finish Shakespeare (along with three other Elizabethan poems).

We begin the lesson by going over some background on Sir Walter Raleigh - see my detailed Power Point Speaker notes below (either directly in the Power Point or as a PDF).  

Next we read two of his poems that stand alone (again - see my speaker notes below on the Power Point).  The two poems are "To His Son" and "What is Our Life a Play of Passion".  The "To His Son" poem is hilarious in a very dark way - he warns his son about misbehaving - by saying may a mischevious boy, a rope, and a gallows never come together!  I then show a picture of Raleigh's son - and you can "see where he is coming from"!

"What is our life? A Play of Passion" is a very important poem.  It predates Shakespeare's speech (that I will compare it to after we read the poem) from As You Like It: "All the World's a Stage".  Again - see my notes in the Power Point (or the PDF) below.  There are some great moments - and "self checks" for the students (did they stop to figure out what something meant when they read it on their own).

The next part of the lesson is about Christopher Marlowe.  Like Raleigh, we briefly go over biographical material.  And I ask the students for permission to read his poem "The Passionate Shepherd to His Love" in a very "caricatured" way.  I preface my reading by saying - "This is not me - but the voice I imagine of Marlowe's Shepherd".  I then read the poem aloud as a disgusting, "lounge lizard" on the make.  Which is exactly what I believe the Shepherd to be.  We don't spend much if any time talking about the poem - it is pretty much all on the surface.  I do caution the class not to get the idea that this is the best Marlowe has to offer - and in fact, he is much much better than this.

And then we get to Raleigh's incredible reply to Marlowe's poem, "The Nymph's Reply".  I let the students know it is not just their teacher - but pretty much everyone who knew what a horrible poem Marlowe had written.  Shallow, callow, and lurid - it was not about life - but was a saccharine piece of verse designed for seduction.  Raleigh's poem, on the other hand, is miraculous and real.

Rather than going over my lesson in this section (there is just so much) - I have instead updated my Power Point presentation with speaker notes - that take you step by step for how I handled this lesson.  In addition to the notes being on the Power Point (when you want to view them) - I have also saved it a PDF so you can see the notes next to each slide as annotations that you can turn on or off.

After we read and discuss Raleigh's "Nymph's Reply", we listen to two songs.  I preface our listening by telling the students that one of these songs will look at its subject in a similar way to Marlowe's Nymph poem - while the other will look with a realistic (yet ultimately - like Raleigh's Nymph - hopeful) eye.  Anytime remaining we will talk about the songs and their relationship to the poems (and to works like "The Wife of Bath's Prologue".

Finally - there is the barest of lesson notes - but the notes on the Power Point are the definitive source of how I conducted this Lesson.

Power Point & Detailed Lesson Instructions

This is the Power Point that you would use in class - along with the Power Point are very detailed Speaker Notes that really lay out the lesson (if you choose to go that way).  You can turn them on within Power Point

This version of the Power Point is mainly supplied to give you instructions - if you don't have Power Point.  You can always view the above Power Point as a Google Slides Presentation (though I'm not sure how well it would preserve the Speaker Notes).  In that case, this is a PDF of the Slide Show along with annotations (that can be turned on or off) that give the same detailed instructions for the lesson.

The Poems with Notes & Lesson Instructions

This version of the text book reading (only the Nymph poems) has my notes - both my general notes and some instructions for the lesson.  A much more complete set of instructions for today's lesson can be found directly above (in the Power Point speaker notes)

This is the same handout found below to give students so that they can cover it with their notes as the class goes on - only in this case - it is covered with my notes.

Handouts - The Poems/Songs & Quiz

Two Nymph Poems / Two Songs       Docx     PDF

When you get to the Nymph poems (Marlowe, Raleigh), you want your students to put their textbook versions of the poems away (with all of the footnotes and annotations) and take out these versions of the two poems - they have plenty of room for notes - and NO footnotes to give the critical thinking away.
On the backside are the two songs that you will listen to: 1) "Love and Marriage"  and 2) "That's the Way that I've Always Heard it Should Be".  Make sure you screen these songs and speak ahead of time to any sensitive students (especially those that may have been going through events similar to those depicted in the song.  At the same time - wow!  These songs can really make the nymph poems come alive and once again show (rather than tell) your students how little things really have changed.  Also on this side are some quotes from the 2 poems to help your students make the connections and a great quote from "The Wife of Bath's Prologue" by Chaucer to help connect the poems to that work.

Two Nymph Poems Quiz    Docx     PDF

As I said in my lesson overview - I very often skip this quiz.  The students have already taken a Raleigh Quiz (in their previous lesson on Elizabeth/Raleigh).  This quiz focusses on Christopher Marlowe and the two Nymph poems.

Lesson Plan Notes

Two Nymph Poems Lesson Plan     PDF

There is not that much here - but I want to include it if no other reason than to show how these plans develop along with the idea that the earlier in my career - the less notes I used to conduct my class.

Remote Enhancements 

This can all be done remotely of course -  The Power Point included makes doing this remotely as effective (I really believe this) as in person.
 

Songs for Today's Class

Here are  the two songs that I play after we read the two Nymph poems - see my Lesson Overview and the Slide Notes in the Power Point.  The first song is "Love and Marriage" sung by Frank Sinatra  and "That's The Way I've Always Heard it Should Be" by Carly Simon.

The lyrics to the songs are found on the handout above.

WorldEnoughandTime2NymphPoems.m4a

Class Recordings 

Audio - an audio recording of this class from 2016


What's Next & Unit Home Page

               Edmund Spenser - The Danger & Allure of Allegory Group Work: The Group Work uses Spenser's "The Faerie Queen" as an example of how allegory can actually detract from a work.  Though I hope I do not preach - I do want to expose them to another point of view.  There is also an Illuminated Text that I made of one of my favorite Spenser poems - and a poem that will wonderfully plant some seeds in the students' minds for the Shakespeare Sonnets that are to come soon.

WHAT CAME BEFORE:

  Raleigh & Elizabeth I Group Work

Thoughts on the Lesson 

Sometimes it feels like all of these uber important lessons come in a bunch.  First Wyatt and Howard - now these.  And then the next lesson is Shakespeare's Sonnets.  But I earnestly believe you have to build up to things.  Wyatt and Howard are good - but they're not in Raleigh's league.  Raleigh is good - but his poems are a precursor for what is to come with Shakespeare.  The ending of today's lesson - the Carly Simon song is so powerful - make sure you leave yourself enough time to talk about it and decompress...