"He won't get far on hot air and fantasy."
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen - Movie & Questions: Students will watch a film - answering some questions immediately - and more involved thinking prompts at home. I showed this movie, and assigned these questions nearly every year that I taught British Literature. I still remember seeing it for the first time in 1988 (as I was about to embark on my teaching career) and thinking: "Wow, this movie is really about the contrast between the Enlightenment and The Romantic Age. I couldn't wait to get students to see the same connection - and it was a perfect way to bring those two eras to the students' minds one more time - and to write a bunch of mini-essays (that's what these movie questions - the thinking ones any way - really are) about that connect - before we begin the Victorian Era. As with nearly all of my Movie Questions - there are two sets of questions - the ones in regular type (sometimes these are in bold) to be answered as they're watching the film - to help keep them engaged, and the questions written in italics - the thinking questions or "mini-essays" to be completed at home, on their own time. There is also an Extra Credit very short essay that has the students look at the idea of how imagination is portrayed in the movie and the original story.
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen - Movie Questions (see my page on Movie Questions). You can also see my first film that I showed in this class, The Return of Martin Guerre, for more reasoning on how and why I choose a specific movie. In a nutshell there are two different types of questions - those not in italics that the students answer while they are watching the movie (it keeps them focused and on track) and those questions in italics that the students answer for homework. Each of the latter questions is a kind of mini-essay that requires them to use what they found in their reading of the novel, our discussions & group works, and their viewing of the movie.
Here are the instructions from the handout (found below) and the first question which is a bit different - students need to look for something ("The Big Question") during the entire showing of the film (which takes 2 or 3 days - sometimes if I showed it in 3 days, I would give students time after showing the segment to work on the movie questions):
As you watch this film, you are to try and reason out, why I am having you watch it (this is the Big Question of this assignment and is worth 50 points by itself). Though you may be watching this while studying an other era (ie The Victorians), you need to reach back to the era of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Shelley, Byron, and Blake. In other words, what does it have to do with the Romantics? You may find the excerpt I gave you from the introduction to The Lyrical Ballads helpful. I believe this film fits in quite well with what we've studied. The mystery that you must unravel is, how does it fit in, and what does it specifically address that we've looked at. Answer this big question after you’ve answered all the other questions on these three sheets. Put it last, and label it BIG QUESTION. Make sure you read the introduction to all of these handouts, and take notes on what you think the answer is as you go along.
There's also an extra credit assignment on the last page of the student handout. The students are given an excerpt from the Baron Munchausen story (from the 19th century) along with 15 illustrations of that episode. They are then asked the following: Consider the text from the written Adventures of Baron Munchausen and the 12 different drawings by 12 different artists that have been rendered from that scene. Using all you have learned this year (imagination (Coleridge), reader-centered literary criticism, deconstruction, the Shaper, and everything else) write a short one page essay with a thesis of your own making. Consider the possibilities of all of these drawings (all very different) from one short paragraph of text. Do this AFTER you answer the movie questions – they should help focus your ideas.
Here is a synopsis of the movie: In Terry Gilliam’s 1988 fantasy, an eighteenth-century city under siege by the Turks is staging a play about the legendary Baron Munchausen when the real, elderly Baron (John Neville) interrupts, insisting the stage version gets his adventures wrong. Backed by a young girl named Sally Salt (Sarah Polley), he sets out to rescue the city by reuniting his four gifted companions: a lightning-fast runner, a marksman, a man with extraordinary hearing, and a man of enormous strength. Their quest carries them to the Moon, the fiery workshop of Vulcan beneath Mount Etna, and the belly of a giant sea monster, all while the Baron clashes with Horatio Jackson, the coldly rational “Age of Reason” official who scorns imagination and wonder. The film blurs the line between truth and tall tale, and it ends by celebrating storytelling and fantasy over cold logic.
The trailer can be found here.
PLEASE NOTE (FOR THIS HANDOUT) - the immediate questions are NOT boldfaced, but the at-home thoughtful questions are italicized. From the handout: As you watch this film, you are to try and reason out, why I am having you watch it (this is the Big Question of this assignment and is worth 50 points by itself). Though you may be watching this while studying an other era (ie The Victorians), you need to reach back to the era of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Shelley, Byron, and Blake. In other words, what does it have to do with the Romantics? You may find the excerpt I gave you from the introduction to The Lyrical Ballads helpful. I believe this film fits in quite well with what we've studied. The mystery that you must unravel is, how does it fit in, and what does it specifically address that we've looked at.
Here is the link to JustWatch.com - where you can find where The Adventures of Baron Munchausen is streaming.
It is more than possible to watch films together with your class - usually that means having the video you are watching on your computer and sharing the screen with students. You can also keep the comment window open to share things with them (just don't get too distracting). You can also see if they are paying attention or not.
The poor Victorian Era. Because it is nearly the end of the year - we have run out of time and only have time to do a cursory study of Victorian Literature. In addition, the students were usually wrapping up their Research Papers - so it became impossible to assign a lot of outside writing. In fact, we never did read anything by the most well-known of Victorian authors, Charles Dickens. I thought I'd give him the quote (which really does a great job of describing - in addition to Revolutionary France - the Victorian Era. Many of the assignments that we did do were geared towards giving the students more guidance with their Research Papers (killing two birds with one stone). And yet, there are some very important texts - some very important lessons ("The Lady of Shallot", "Dover Beach") in this too short Unit.
I discovered this film during a short run of a Foriegn Film Club that the students asked me to sponsor. We watched it and I fell in love with the movie - and saw how many wonderful critical links there were with All Quiet on the Western Front.